Phase 3 of a Nonprofit Merger: Integration Planning (or Transition Planning)

The integration planning stage, often called transition planning, bridges the gap between due diligence and full implementation. At this point, the organizations have agreed to merge in principle, but the legal process is still underway. While many decisions can be made in advance, there will still be areas of uncertainty and ambiguity until the merger is finalized. Some details may remain confidential, especially if staff, donors, or community partners have not yet been fully informed.

Too often, this stage is underestimated or brushed off with the belief that “we’ll figure it out as we go.” This is a significant risk. Without a clear and intentional plan, integration can become reactive, leading to confusion, service disruptions, and weakened stakeholder confidence. For executive directors and board members, this stage is the opportunity to proactively design how the new organization will function, from governance to staffing to fundraising strategies, so that once the merger is official, momentum is not lost.

Strong integration planning ensures that the first days and months after the merger run smoothly, programs remain stable, and funders and donors maintain confidence in the merged organization’s ability to deliver on its mission.

Shortcut - Links to other nonprofit merger phases:

Phase 1: The Exploration Stage
Phase 2: Due Diligence and Strategic Planning
Phase 3: Integration Planning (or Transition Planning)
Phase 4: Implementation (or Transition)
Phase 5: Transition to "Business as Usual" 

Key Activities in the Integration Planning Stage

Integration planning is the time to anticipate and plan out operational, cultural, and strategic needs so both organizations are prepared to function as one from day one.

1. Form a Transition Team

A transition team is essential for keeping the process organized and ensuring no critical area is overlooked. Think of it as a nonprofit program management and change management team for the merger.

• Include leaders from programs, operations, fundraising, communications, and nonprofit org design.
• Assign a lead who is responsible for program managing the transition.
• Assign clear roles and responsibilities for each functional area.
• Schedule regular meetings to track progress, manage interdependencies, and address concerns.
  

2. Define Indicators of Success

Establishing clear success metrics will help measure progress and guide decisions through implementation and post-merger.

• Identify short-term, medium-term, and long-term goals for integration.
  
• Include both operational benchmarks (system integration, staffing alignment) and mission-driven outcomes (expanded reach, increased fundraising capacity).
  
• Ensure funder and donor expectations are considered in defining success.
  

3. Finalize the New Organizational Design

A merged nonprofit needs a well-structured design that supports both strategic priorities and operational realities.

• Determine leadership structure, reporting lines, and decision-making authority.
  
• Align teams to avoid duplication and ensure clarity of roles.
  
• Integrate fundraising operations early to protect donor relationships and ensure revenue continuity.
  

4. Create Functional Area Plans

At this stage, the goal is to develop a detailed project plan for each major function or department of the nonprofit organization. These plans outline the specific activities, decisions, and timelines that will guide the transition, and they will later be project-managed and executed once the merger officially closes. A functional approach ensures no area is overlooked and that each team understands its responsibilities.

• Programs & Services - Map how programs will integrate, identify any service overlap, and outline steps to maintain service continuity for clients and the community.
  
• Finance & Compliance - Align budgeting processes, financial reporting systems, accounting software, internal controls, and compliance requirements.
  
• Technology & Data - Plan for merging donor databases, CRM systems, websites, communication tools, and IT infrastructure.
  
• Fundraising & Development - Design joint fundraising campaigns, integrate grant pipelines, and create a unified case for support to signal strength and unity to donors and funders.
  
• Human Resources - Review compensation structures, align benefits, and plan onboarding for staff from both organizations.
  

By defining these functional plans in advance, the new organization can move quickly after legal close, minimizing disruptions and reinforcing confidence among funders, donors, and the community.

While every nonprofit merger is unique, the planning areas to consider are similar from one merger to another. Ask us for our detailed nonprofit merger due diligence checklist. Do NOT reinvent the wheel!

5. Develop a Stakeholder Communication Strategy

Transparent communication builds trust and reduces uncertainty.

• Create tailored messages for staff, board members, donors, funders, and community partners.
  Deter
• mine the appropriate timing for announcements, particularly if the merger is still confidential.
  
• Engage key funders early to reassure them of stability and to invite input on integration priorities.
  

Decisions to Make in the Integration Planning Stage

While not every detail can be finalized before the legal merger, there are critical decisions that should be made during this phase to set the new organization up for a strong launch. These early determinations help avoid confusion and ensure that funders, donors, and the community see a clear, unified direction.

Key decisions include:

• Leadership roles - Decide who will serve as the new CEO or executive director, and how other senior leadership positions will be assigned or restructured.
  
• Board composition – Determine how board members from each organization will be represented in the new governance structure and establish any term limits or rotation schedules.
  
• Program direction - Decide which programs will continue as is, which will be merged, and which may be sunset if they no longer align with the merged mission or strategic priorities. Ensure these decisions are made with input from program staff, funders, and community stakeholders.
  
• Fundraising priorities - Identify which campaigns, events, or donor relationships require immediate attention post-merger, and plan coordinated outreach to reassure supporters.
  
• Community engagement - Define how the merged entity will communicate its mission, vision, and value to the community in the first 90 days, including opportunities for public visibility and celebration.

By making these decisions before legal close, both organizations can reduce uncertainty, protect key relationships, and enter the post-merger period with clarity and momentum.

Risks in the Nonprofit Merger Integration Planning Stage

The merger you are planning is on top of your day job (and your staff's). There is limited capacity to plan. Proactive planning is critical to reduce risks. Here are the risk areas we've witnessed the most with executive directors and board members:

• Planning in a vacuum – Failing to engage the right people in planning can lead to missed perspectives and weaker buy-in.
  
• Unrealistic timelines – Rushing integration planning can create gaps that are harder to fix later.
  
• Overlooking fundraising readiness – If donor communication plans are incomplete, there is a risk of losing revenue momentum.
  
• Ignoring cultural integration – Culture should be addressed during planning, not just during implementation.
  
• Underestimating the scope of post-merger work – Overlooking the full breadth of activities that need to be executed once the merger is official can result in confusion, delays, and missed opportunities during the critical first months.
  
• Delaying critical leadership decisions – Postponing choices about the CEO, executive team, or other key roles can create uncertainty, weaken confidence among staff and funders, and slow early momentum. To be clear, some org design decisions can wait. Put not the senior leadership team.
  

Looking Ahead to Phase 4 - Nonprofit Merger Implementation

Once integration planning is complete and the merger is legally finalized, the focus shifts to execution. In Phase 4, organizations activate their integration plans, launch the merged org structure and “brand” publicly, and begin operating as a unified entity. The quality of your integration planning directly influences how smooth and successful that stage will be.

How Two Five One Consulting Supports Integration Planning

At Two Five One Consulting, we combine nonprofit leadership experience, business M&A insights, fundraising strategy, and nonprofit org design expertise to help organizations navigate the critical integration planning stage. We work with executive directors, boards, and senior leadership teams to create practical, actionable plans that protect programs, retain donor trust, and set the merged entity up for long-term success. 

Our experience in mergers spans guiding nonprofit leaders through all stages of nonprofit M&A, as well as leading merger exploration, due diligence, planning, and implementation phases as a business leader at Accenture M&A and Vanguard. 

While we do not provide legal or tax advice, we work closely with experienced attorneys and CPAs to ensure all angles are covered. We are happy to introduce you to some trusted resources in those areas of expertise.

While we do not provide legal or tax advice, we collaborate closely with attorneys and CPAs to ensure all plans align with compliance requirements and mission priorities.

Phase 3 – Integration (Transition) Planning FAQs

1. What is integration planning in a nonprofit merger? 

Integration planning, also called transition planning, is the phase where the merging organizations design how they will operate together after the legal merger. This includes aligning programs, operations, fundraising strategies, governance, staffing, and communications.

2. Who should be on the merger transition team?

A transition team should include leaders from both organizations: executive directors, senior staff (finance, programs, fundraising, HR), and board members. This group manages planning, monitors progress, and addresses challenges before and after the merger.

3. How do we keep funders engaged during transition planning?

Share your high-level integration vision, anticipated benefits, and how donor support will be used to strengthen programs and community impact. Where appropriate, invite funders to provide input or support the transition process financially.

4. How do we plan when some details are still uncertain?

Identify the decisions that will inevitably need to be made, such as governance structure, staffing, program alignment, and outline preliminary approaches. Acknowledge uncertainty but prepare frameworks so decisions can be made quickly when clarity comes.

5. How do we define success for our transition plan?

Success indicators should address mission delivery, fundraising performance, program reach and quality, cultural integration, and stakeholder trust. They should be measurable and time-bound, guiding post-merger evaluation.